Arek777
Member
- Messages
- 14
- Sep 4, 2014
- #1
I am running my JMP-1 through ART SLA1 into WGS Veteran 30 (60W) and MC90 (90W).
Can I crank it up all the way without a risk of blowing the speakers?
My wishfull thinking here is that since they are guitar speakers, and tube guitar amps put out aprox. 50% more power when at distorted/overdriven 10, and since the speaker rated at 60W is made for 60W amp, but could handle 90W - I should be OK at 90% volume for WGS and 100% for MC90.
GCDEF
Silver Supporting Member
- Messages
- 29,254
- Sep 4, 2014
- #2
You should be okay. Be careful that you don't push the ART into clipping.
Fulldrive-1
Member
- Messages
- 5,926
- Sep 4, 2014
- #3
100w amp will blow a 60w speaker. Maybe sooner, maybe later, but blow.
Arek777
Member
- Messages
- 14
- Sep 4, 2014
- #4
That's what I am afraid about.
I got two 250W speakers today.
Braciola
Gold Supporting Member
- Messages
- 6,610
- Sep 4, 2014
- #5
Arek777 said:
I am running my JMP-1 through ART SLA1 into WGS Veteran 30 (60W) and MC90 (90W).
Can I crank it up all the way without a risk of blowing the speakers?
My wishfull thinking here is that since they are guitar speakers, and tube guitar amps put out aprox. 50% more power when at distorted/overdriven 10, and since the speaker rated at 60W is made for 60W amp, but could handle 90W - I should be OK at 90% volume for WGS and 100% for MC90.
If you have a 60W speaker & a 90W speaker wired together in the cab, the total handling wattage for that cab is 120 watts.
You take the lesser wattage speaker and times it by the number of speakers in the cab.
If you're running the power amp in stereo (one side per speaker...... that's a different story)
J M Fahey
Member
- Messages
- 3,722
- Sep 4, 2014
- #6
60W speaker into 100W amp
You should have called this thread:
60W speaker + 90W speaker into 100W amp .
Not the same by a country mile
And yes, I agree that the lower powered speaker defines cabinet total power handling
Ilduce
And now for something completely different!
- Messages
- 4,593
- Sep 4, 2014
- #7
I could be wrong, but from what I've read it's my understanding that you add the speaker wattages together and the total is the power rating. Sort of like my 4x12 is rated at 350 watts, it has 2 G12t75's at 75 watts each and 2 Elite 100's at 100 watts each, 2 x 75 and 2 x 100 = 350. At least that's my understanding. So yours would be 60 + 90 = 150. I'm very interested to find out if this is correct!
IM4Tone
Member
- Messages
- 3,769
- Sep 4, 2014
- #8
Ilduce said:
I could be wrong, but from what I've read it's my understanding that you add the speaker wattages together and the total is the power rating. Sort of like my 4x12 is rated at 350 watts, it has 2 G12t75's at 75 watts each and 2 Elite 100's at 100 watts each, 2 x 75 and 2 x 100 = 350. At least that's my understanding. So yours would be 60 + 90 = 150. I'm very interested to find out if this is correct!
Wrong.
Braciola said:
If you have a 60W speaker & a 90W speaker wired together in the cab, the total handling wattage for that cab is 120 watts.
You take the lesser wattage speaker and times it by the number of speakers in the cab.
If you're running the power amp in stereo (one side per speaker...... that's a different story)
sharpshooter
Member
- Messages
- 4,009
- Sep 4, 2014
- #9
Since speakers also have operational similarities to an inductor, that if the impedence ratings are the same, than should'nt the formula for power be expressed as a function of reciprocals?
If so, than the power handeling ability of a 60 watt, plus a 90 watt, (the speakers wired in parallel), would be ~75 watts.
To clarify, if wired in parallel, than the power handeling ability is greater than the lesser speaker, but less than the greater speaker,,if wired in series, than the speaker with the lowest rating becomes the limiting factor.
Last edited:
Ilduce
And now for something completely different!
- Messages
- 4,593
- Sep 4, 2014
- #10
I believe you guys, it's just weird that the manufacturer got the specs wrong for my 4x12. I'm sure it's not the first time and won't be the last! Luckily I don't have to worry about it, at least for now cause I'm not using any amps that are rated more than 50 watts.
Arek777
Member
- Messages
- 14
- Sep 4, 2014
- #11
I have actually hooked them up to two separate outputs. Each pumping out 100W.
GCDEF
Silver Supporting Member
- Messages
- 29,254
- Sep 4, 2014
- #12
Arek777 said:
I have actually hooked them up to two separate outputs. Each pumping out 100W.
That's a really bad idea
Braciola
Gold Supporting Member
- Messages
- 6,610
- Sep 4, 2014
- #13
sharpshooter said:
If so, than the power handeling ability of a 60 watt, plus a 90 watt, (the speakers wired in parallel), would be ~75 watts.
So, lets check your theory:
If you ran a 25 watt Celestion Greenback in parallel with a 200 watt EVM12L, you would get a total that handles 112.5 watts?
Try cranking a Marshall Super Lead through that 112.5 watt cab, and let me know how many seconds it takes to fry that Greenback.
Hacksaw
Time Warped
Gold Supporting Member
- Messages
- 10,214
- Sep 4, 2014
- #14
Braciola said:
So, lets check your theory:
If you ran a 25 watt Celestion Greenback in parallel with a 200 watt EVM12L, you would get a total that handles 112.5 watts?
Try cranking a Marshall Super Lead through that 112.5 watt cab, and let me know how many seconds it takes to fry that Greenback.
14.2 seconds!! Lol. Or less.
Lowest wattage speaker times the number of speakers in your cab equals max wattage.
Greenback. 25 watt and 200 watt ev In a 2x12 cab. 50 watts .
sharpshooter
Member
- Messages
- 4,009
- Sep 4, 2014
- #15
Braciola said:
So, lets check your theory:
If you ran a 25 watt Celestion Greenback in parallel with a 200 watt EVM12L, you would get a total that handles 112.5 watts?
Try cranking a Marshall Super Lead through that 112.5 watt cab, and let me know how many seconds it takes to fry that Greenback.
I did'nt propose anything as a theory, I put a question mark in my post,
and, my last paragraph is totally correct.
Braciola
Gold Supporting Member
- Messages
- 6,610
- Sep 4, 2014
- #16
Hacksaw said:
14.2 seconds!! Lol.
I think 14.2 is a bit optimistic, I'd put my money on less than 3 seconds.
Arek777
Member
- Messages
- 14
- Sep 4, 2014
- #17
This is going off the rail....
JDutch
Gold Supporting Member
- Messages
- 2,312
- Sep 4, 2014
- #18
Arek777 said:
I am running my JMP-1 through ART SLA1 into WGS Veteran 30 (60W) and MC90 (90W).
Can I crank it up all the way without a risk of blowing the speakers?
My wishfull thinking here is that since they are guitar speakers, and tube guitar amps put out aprox. 50% more power when at distorted/overdriven 10, and since the speaker rated at 60W is made for 60W amp, but could handle 90W - I should be OK at 90% volume for WGS and 100% for MC90.
People already have chimed in with the correct answer to the speaker cabinets max wattage: 120 watts. However, keep in mind that a lot of amps, particularly amps derived from Marshall designs, produce wattages well in excess of their nominal wattages when you crank them up, sometimes as such as double their nominal wattages.
For example, I, personally, try to run a 50 watt Marshall into an 80 to 100 watt cabinet if I'm going to crank it without an attenuator or master volume.
Hacksaw
Time Warped
Gold Supporting Member
- Messages
- 10,214
- Sep 4, 2014
- #19
sharpshooter said:
I did'nt propose anything as a theory, I put a question mark in my post,
and, my last paragraph is totally correct.
About that last paragraph, Uh, you sure about that? I'd like to see the math, please.
GilmourD
Member
- Messages
- 1,425
- Sep 5, 2014
- #20
sharpshooter said:
Since speakers also have operational similarities to an inductor, that if the impedence ratings are the same, than should'nt the formula for power be expressed as a function of reciprocals?
If so, than the power handeling ability of a 60 watt, plus a 90 watt, (the speakers wired in parallel), would be ~75 watts.
To clarify, if wired in parallel, than the power handeling ability is greater than the lesser speaker, but less than the greater speaker,,if wired in series, than the speaker with the lowest rating becomes the limiting factor.
By that logic then a 2x12 with two 50 watt speakers would only be 50 watts. We know that's not true. It's 100 watts.
You're spreading out the wattage between the speakers. In a 4x12 being hit with 100
actualwatts each speaker is dissipating 25 watts nominally. Now that would be fine if you're running, say, four 30 watt G12H Anniversaries. However, if you mix two G12H Anniversaries with two 20 watt Heritage Series G12Ms then you're going to run into trouble. Even though you would think that the wattages of the speakers add up to 100 watts, you'd be putting 25 watts each on the two 20 watt speakers. Therefore, in that example, you could safely take up to 80 actual watts with that configuration.
You must log in or register to reply here.